I attended the StartupEmpire conference yesterday, and had an absolute blast. Thanks to the organizers for putting this on.
Here are some of my notes. Sorry I don’t have time to make this more concise.
Conference format:
- Timing: the original 2-day schedule was just too much time away from product development for me. They scaled it down to 1 day, which was perfect: everyone stayed focused and we got a lot done. Given that the audience is entrepreneurs or would-be entrepreneurs, time is a key constraint.
- Networking: there was lots of opportunity to socialize inbetween and after the talks. I found the crowd very friendly, and I think keeping the numbers low was vital to this. I didn’t get much out of EventVue, as a pre-conference tool, but I probably didn’t put enough into it. Perhaps more useful after the fact.
- Content: good mix of practical advice with inspiration. There wasn’t a speaker I didn’t like. I found Austin Hill particularly inspiring and worthwhile. As a bright entrepreneur and angel investor with great willingness to share his learnings, he was a real pleasure to listen to. I also enjoyed listening to Craig Hayashi of Maple Leaf Angels. He is doing a blog post series on angel financing, over on Startup North.
- Students: I loved seeing local students helping out as volunteers in exchange for tickets. Yes, yes, yes! We need to graduate more students who are fired up about creating original works and starting their own ventures, not just students who are trained to plug into existing businesses.
- Cost: at $65, this was a steal. For me, the value provided was easily $100+.
- Venue: This is London was pretty much perfect. I’d guess the crowd was around 150 people.
We need more startup community leadership: I would love to see more local people step up to help nurture the startup culture and community in Toronto. It seems we have a very small handful — David Crow and Jevon MacDonald chief most notable among them — who do the heavy lifting at the events I’m aware of. Yes, there are smaller events that cater to niche interest groups (mmm, like, Ruby on Rails nights — love ‘em), and those are absolutely necessary, but not sufficient. In particular I would love to see some local Angels, VCs, and prominent entrepreneurs step to the fore. The municipal government, Ontario Centres for Excellence and perhaps MaRS should take a sponsorship role. I personally want to devote time to doing this next year. David Cohen spoke about what he and his colleagues have done with TechStars in Boulder, and I think it’s a fabulous example of what a few people can do with some spare cycles. More on this another day… it’s a big topic.
Inspiration = oxygen for entrepreneurs: one of the most difficult things I’ve found about starting a new venture is the sheer negativity you often encounter. Lots of people — the majority, I’ve found — are biased to believe that all startup ideas fail. It is certainly true that most startup ventures don’t make it past the first year, but not all. If would-be entrepreneurs took all that the doom and gloom to heart, there would be no startup innovation. So I found it very encouraging to hear several of the speakers advise founders to stay focused and ignore the noise. Hugh MacLeod, in the second-to-last talk, said it even more firmly: “Ignore everybody. Good ideas have lonely childhoods.”
Milestones should include risk reduction: I find this concept particularly useful. When you’re planning product milestones (or sprints, or whatever jargon you want to use), a key part of the planning is what risks you’re going to reduce or eliminate. For instance, if a big risk is “Will customers think our product design smells like doggie doo?”, then you’d better have a milestone that includes testing your product and acting on customer feedback. Or if you’re worried about your server falling over, you should deal with that. While a risk reduction plan is essential if you’re going to pitch professional investors for funding, it’s just as valid if you’re going it alone. You owe it to yourself, your customers, and your investors to identify risks and make concrete plans to address them.
“Lifestyle Businesses”: Several of the speakers in the professional investment arena mentioned how important it is to distinguish clearly between “lifestyle businesses” and businesses that a VC or angel would invest in. A lifestyle business is one that makes enough money for you to live comfortably, but is highly unlikely to bring in the high returns a pro investor is looking for. (Hmm… I wonder how Craig Newmark would have described Craigslist ten years ago?) As an entrepreneur it’s essential you get honest and clear with yourself about this, for otherwise you are wasting your time and the time of those you’re pitching to.
Austin Hill highlights:
- Austin used the analogy of a road trip to help convey some of the key things startups need to know. So, …
- “Keep your eye on the fuel gauge [money and other key resources], but also on the road ahead [competition, industry trends, etc]“
- Cash and runway is a critical asset. “You must have enough gas to reach the next service station. Don’t plan a lot of sightseeing trips.”
- Fit your product to the market’s needs. “Nobody wants to invest in a rickshaw, a hummer, or a submersible RV. Build a Prius.”
- (with investors): “You must present a clear, believable picture of how you will build a defensible market segment in 3-5 years”.
- “What to pack”: customer acquisition plan; analytics, in particular pirate metrics; waterfall and cash model;’ risk reduction model
- Look at Product Planner for user flows (boy how much did that domain name cost?) and Balsamiq for software wireframes and mockups
- “Build meaning”
- Advice for tough economic times
- potential customers = who is losing the most money, or most desperate to offset the downturn’s effects
- go talent shopping: “topgrade”
- watch layoff rolls
- get good at outsourcing (TopCoder, eLance)
- think diversely on fundraising strategies: friends, family, angels, VCs, strategic investors
- on pitching:
- the job of a pitch is to grab someone’s attention and convince them to ask for more.
- “talk to people’s hearts, minds, and wallets”. In that order.
- you must be able to speak fluently about competitors and industry trends
- offer customer references
- don’t talk about features
- referencing well-known real world parallels can be powerful
- “where are we” helps, e.g. “60 days out of a beta”
- “here is what we know and here is what we don’t know”
- on red flags when hiring people:
- lack of passion
- people who can’t pass “practical exams”, i.e. work tasks that test basic competence
- culture fit
- inability to discuss results — “every hire should have a mental scorecard of what they’ve accomplished in the last 30, 60 and 90 days”.
- on SRED credits: “There are way too many Canadian businesses eating zombie food. Walking wounded, should have died years ago.”
Typical Valuation Range for early stage startups
I believe this was a comment from Scott Pelton from GrowthWorks… he said he’s seeing valuations typically in the $1M to $3M range for initial funding. Higher end = great management team, product is real, and perhaps IP is particularly well protected.
“What should a startup CEO get paid?”
This was a great audience question asked of the professional investors who were presenting. A good deal of squirming ensued.
- Rick Segal: “JLA has funded a large range of companies, and the CEO salaries range from $0 (all equity) to $110K”.
- Craig Hayashi from Maple Leaf Angels: [long hesitation]… “it depends”… but eventually he held out $75K as reasonable.
- Austin Hill: “enough so that the CEO doesn’t need to take a 2nd job [keep them focused] or have troubles in family life. For a professional in their 30’s, maybe 90K to a max of 140K, depending on experience. For someone younger, a lot less may be approriate.”
On advertising-based business models for web startups
The speakers were uniformly negative about business models based solely on ad revenue. I’m sure a lot of that has to do with the current economic climate — everyone’s spending less, and ads are easy to cut — but there seems also to be a backing away from the hype about ads being a magical biz model for web ventures. A few people voiced a preference for transactional biz models, and for focusing more on enterprise-centric products rather than consumer plays.
Microsoft BizSpark = free stuff for startups
Microsoft sponsored the event and it showed… job well done. They also talked about BizSpark, which is worth any startup looking at. Check it.
Technorati Tags: startupempire